Public survey reveals attitudes to sentencing in Scotland
A new report published today (Monday 2 September) by the Scottish Sentencing Council explores public knowledge and attitudes towards sentencing in Scotland, revealing that the majority of respondents view is that sentences were too lenient.
The research was conducted as an opinion poll of 1,000 adults across Scotland between March and April of this year by Ipsos MORI.
Respondents were asked for their views on what the purposes of sentencing should be; how current sentencing is perceived; their awareness of different sentencing options and what sentences ought to be given for causing death by driving offences and some sexual offences.
The Scottish Sentencing Council is now seeking views on guidelines on the sentencing process, which is open for public consultation.
Kate Wallace, CEO of Victim Support Scotland, said:
“The results of the ‘Public Perceptions of Sentencing’ national survey demonstrates that there is a real gap between the perception and reality of sentencing in Scotland. More must be done to address the misconceptions around custodial sentences, and the lack of confidence in the effectiveness of community sentencing, if the general public and victims are to feel that justice has been served.
“The ongoing consultation by the Sentencing Council offers a real opportunity to increase public knowledge and understanding of how our courts work. 56% of respondents to this survey feel that the submission of a guilty plea should make no difference to the sentence handed down, this shows that our criminal justice system should fundamentally be about providing justice to victims of crime, not saving courts time.
“56% of respondents to this survey feel that the submission of a guilty plea should make no difference to the sentence handed down, this shows that our criminal justice system should fundamentally be about providing justice to victims of crime, not saving courts time.”
The Scottish Sentencing Council undertook this work to broaden its understanding of Scottish public attitudes towards sentencing in general, and to explore in more depth how the public views the sentencing of particular offences. Although some research is undertaken on the criminal justice system in general, particularly as part of the Scottish Crime and Justice Survey, this project fills a gap in understanding around Scottish attitudes towards sentencing.
The survey revealed that:
- 62% were confident that Scotland’s criminal justice system is fair to all.
- Those who thought that crime in their local area had increased were most likely to have a lack of confidence in the system.
- ‘People were more likely to say the emphasis should be on rehabilitation when sentencing a young person compared to sentencing an adult’.
- Respondents felt that public protection was the most important purpose of sentencing, followed by rehabilitation of offenders.
- 56% of respondents felt that sentencing in general was too lenient.
- However, when asked how offenders should be sentenced in specific scenarios, the most common response was broadly in line with likely sentences for four out of the five offences covered.
The full report can be found on the Scottish Sentencing Council website.
Latest news and blogs
-
Children (Care and Justice) (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 Debate
At Wednesday’s debate on Stage 3 of the Children (Care and Justice) (Scotland) Bill, we’re asking members of the Criminal Justice Committee to consider the rights of victims who are harmed by 16 and 17-year-olds. Read our briefing to MSPs.
Read more
-
Remote evidence suites
Victim Support Scotland receives £500,000 funding from Scottish Government for specialist remote evidence suites
Read more
-
Victims, Witnesses, and Justice Reform Stage 1 debate
At today’s debate on Stage 1 of the Victim’s, Witnesses, and Justice Reform (Scotland) Bill, we’re asking members of the Criminal Justice Committee to keep victims’ views at the heart of their decision-making. Read our briefing to MSPs:
Read more
-
Victims’ charity seeks support to uphold victims’ rights
Victim Support Scotland, Scotland’s leading national charity for victims, is urging MSPs to consider victim support and information needs in the Children (Care and Justice) (Scotland) Bill as the debate of Stage 3 of the Bill approaches on 24 April.
Read more
-
Join Victim Support Scotland as a charity Trustee
Are you an exceptional leader, ambitious for change to improve victims’ and witnesses’ experiences of the criminal justice system? Leading charity VSS is looking for high calibre and committed professionals to join our Board of Trustees.
Read more
-
The importance of feedback
We always seek to hear from individuals affected by crime about their experiences with our services. This is crucial to ongoing learning and improvement within our work and in informing others about how our support can make a difference. We particularly encourage those who have experienced harm caused by children and young people under 18 to share their views.
Read more
-
Minister goes to court to learn about services for victims and witnesses
As part of Victims’ Awareness Week, Minister for Victims and Community Safety Siobhian Brown visited Edinburgh Sheriff Court for a familiarisation visit.
Read more
-
Bex’s story
Read more
-
Campaign launches to support more victims of crime – press release
Read more
-
Student Volunteering Week – Priya’s story
Read more
-
Student Volunteering Week – Anna’s story
Read more
-
Victim support organisations sign open letter calling for anonymity for children who die as a result of crime
Read more